Legal Protection of Cultural Heritage
Professor Dr. Peter A. Windel
Chair of Procedural and Civil Law
Faculty of Law
Abstract
Our world will only be worth living in through globalization. In a time of political, economic and military disruptions and turmoil, we need to focus on cultural heritage. In doing so, we will preserve people’s understanding of the commonalities of humanity’s cultural roots as well as the specifics of the cultures of individual nations and peoples. However, cultural heritage is also exposed to a variety of threats and dangers. The protection of cultural property is therefore not only a key area of international politics and international co-operation but also requires legal protection.
The working paper provides an overview of this legal protection, which is guaranteed on several levels and by a variety of legal sources. The starting point is the civil law rules on ownership, rights of use and disposal, which are intended to ensure the cultural benefits of the population and to banish tangible cultural assets from the black market. From a German perspective, European, federal and state regulations overlap and complement each other in this respect; in China, there is a special law on cultural heritage in addition to the Civil Code. All in all, there are clear parallels between the Chinese and European legal situation, especially the German one.
In terms of international law, protection is provided by various conventions, which have been supplemented by protocols over time and in some cases overlap. These conventions mainly address not only the protection of cultural property as such, but also armed conflicts and humanitarian aid. Resolutions of the World Security Council are also relevant. It therefore seems worthwhile to assemble this kaleidoscope into a coherent picture.
Any legal protection would remain incomplete without the possibility of criminal sanctions. To this end, substantive standards have been enacted both at national and international criminal law level. However, jurisdiction in such criminal cases is at least as important as the substantive prohibitions and sanctions. The working paper therefore concludes with corresponding remarks.
Key words: UNESCO; World Heritage; Cultural Property; Archaeological Sites; Architectural Monuments; Treasure Trove; Black Market; Armed Conflicts; Natural Disasters; Environmental Damages; Civil Law; International Law; Criminal Law
