China Watch Vol. 6, No. 32, August 2026
An Analysis of the Mechanism Generating the “Brussels Effect on Value Chains”: How EU Automotive Sustainability Standards Are Embedded in Global Value Chain Governance
Chen Yushi and Liu Hongsong
Abstract
The “European Green Deal” has driven the EU’s sustainable automotive regulations to expand from mere tailpipe emission limits to a comprehensive governance framework covering automobiles’ entire lifecycle—including raw materials, production, usage, and recycling. By integrating the “Brussels Effect” with global value chain governance theory, this paper proposes the concept of the “Brussels Effect on Value Chains”: the EU leverages market access through the coupling of horizontal regulatory measures such as sustainability disclosure, due diligence, assurance, and data rules with vertical product regulations concerning batteries, emissions, ecodesign, and end-of-life vehicles. “Chain-leading” enterprises translate these public legal obligations into procurement terms, technical specifications, supplier guidelines, audit procedures, and data interfaces, thereby driving the diffusion of rules throughout the multi-tier supply chain. Through two sub-cases, “battery passports” combined with carbon footprint requirements, and targets for recycled materials in end-of-life vehicles, this article illustrates how compliance obligations are transformed into contractual, verifiable, and data-driven requirements, subsequently catalyzing mandatory environmental upgrades, supplier selection, and the restructuring of value chain networks.
Key terms:
Brussels effect on value chains; battery passports; European Green Deal; sustainability standards.
- Posing the question
The global low-carbon transition is entering a phase driven by regulation. The European Union (EU) first set targets for climate neutrality and resource efficiency through the European Green Deal, and subsequently enshrined the 2050 climate neutrality goal into law via the European Climate Law. Within the automotive industry, the scope of regulation is progressively expanding beyond vehicle product conformity at the point of manufacture to encompass raw material sourcing, production processes, supply chain due diligence, material circularity, and data traceability. Vehicle manufacturers need to continuously generate data regarding carbon emissions, environmental performance, supplier risks, material composition, end-of-life destinations, and recycling, while demonstrating that this information is auditable and subject to accountability.
This shift has given rise to a kind of coupled structure: the “regulation-plus-value chain” structure. The EU defines responsible entities and accountability procedures through horizontal regulations—such as the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) and the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD), and at the same time, it establishes product and lifecycle metrics via vertical regulations, including the Batteries Regulation, the Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation, “Euro 7” emission standards, and the End-of-Life Vehicles Regulation. It then links these various requirements through mechanisms such as Digital Product Passports, third-party assurance, and industry data spaces. Public regulation thus enters the transactional relationship between the chain-leading enterprise and its suppliers, and it is implemented through mechanisms of private governance.
While research on the “Brussels Effect” explains how the EU leverages market size, regulatory capacity, and the indivisibility of production to drive the adoption of its standards by foreign firms, there is limited explanation on how these rules permeate inter-firm relationships and are consistently enforced along supply chains. Research on global value chain governance enables an analysis of how lead firms control suppliers through standards, interfaces, and orders, yet it frequently treats national institutions merely as an external environment. Addressing this, the article poses a core question: How do EU automotive sustainability standards embed themselves into global value chains through the coupling of horizontal institutions and vertical regulations, thereby generating new competitive advantages and barriers to entry within multi-level contractual arrangements and capability configurations?
This study employs embedded process tracing, taking EU regulatory provisions as the starting point. It tracks the sequence of “EU provisions translation by chain leaders à supplier response à value chain outcomes” by integrating materials such as sustainability reports, due diligence reports, supplier codes of conduct, procurement governance information, product passport pilots, and trusted industry data spaces from vehicle manufacturing groups and key suppliers. Two sub-cases illustrate upstream data locking and downstream circular traceability, respectively: battery passport requirements mandate the entry of upstream data covering raw materials, refining, and manufacturing into verifiable interfaces; meanwhile, targets for recycled materials in end-of-life vehicles drive a reverse influence from end-stage recovery back to upstream design and procurement.
- The concept and mechanism of the “Brussels Effect on Value Chains”
The “Brussels effect” reflects the EU’s structural power to shape global business rules through regulation. The EU market has a large capacity, a mature legal system, and relatively stable enforcement expectations. To enter its market, multinational companies often choose to adjust their unified production systems, thus allowing EU standards to cross geographical boundaries. The green transition further integrates environmental goals, industrial competitiveness, and supply chain security into a unified regulatory framework, with procedural requirements, technical standards, and data rules serving as key instruments for the EU to exert external influence. At the same time, however, disparities in implementation within the EU, corporate compliance burdens, and uneven impacts on developing countries may limit the scope and intensity of this external spillover.
Global Value Chain (GVC) governance theory offers a holistic perspective on how market influences and rules are transmitted to enterprises. Lead firms organize cross-border production based on transaction complexity, information codifiability, and supplier capabilities, resulting in governance modes such as market, modular, relational, captive, and hierarchical. The EU’s new sustainability requirements entail extensive process-related, non-financial, and cross-tier information covering areas such as supply chain due diligence, full-lifecycle carbon footprints, raw material sourcing, and environmental risks. This information is more complex than traditional technical specifications and difficult to fully incorporate into concise, standardized contracts. To acquire, verify, and continuously update such information, lead firms need to strengthen collaboration with, as well as monitor and control, their suppliers; consequently, value chain governance is more likely to evolve toward a relational or captive model.
Building on this foundation, this article proposes an “analytical framework for institutionally embedded global value chains.” The EU alters the boundaries of responsibility, transaction complexity, and information codifiability within value chains through measures concerning market access, disclosure, and due diligence obligations; lead firms assume statutory responsibilities and exercise remote governance via contracts, audits, ratings, and data systems. To retain orders and market access, suppliers invest in low-carbon processes, circular materials, and systems for traceability, verification, and data management, resulting in externally driven environmental upgrading. Through this mechanism, public authority makes use of corporate governance tools to penetrate global value chains.
The “Brussels effect on value chains” refers to the process by which the EU leverages market access rules on information disclosure, due diligence, assurance, and data regulation to institutionalize sustainability requirements and extends these mandates upstream and downstream through the contractual terms, supplier codes of conduct, data interfaces, and audit mechanisms of lead firms. This effectively transforms public regulations into mechanisms of private governance within global value chains, thereby altering transactional relationships, governance structures, and corporate boundaries, while driving a systemic restructuring of supply chain capability allocation and environmental performance.
This effect comprises four sequential stages. First, regulatory coupling: horizontal regulations stipulate responsibilities, disclosure requirements, and accountability mechanisms, while vertical regulations define the thresholds that products, materials, and lifecycles must meet. Second, contractual and data transmission: lead firms include regulatory metrics in procurement contracts, technical specifications, supplier scorecards, and product passport fields, extending these requirements to suppliers across multiple tiers of their chains. Third, the reshaping of governance structures: complex compliance information drives up coordination and verification costs; continuous monitoring replaces one-off delivery, and lead firms increasingly assume the role of regulatory agents. Fourth, mandatory environmental upgrading: to retain orders and maintain market access, suppliers upgrade their processes, products, organizational structures, and data capabilities, transforming compliance capacity from an added advantage into a prerequisite for market entry.
The theoretical value of this concept lies in extending regulatory spillover into value chains themselves. The vehicle for this spillover has expanded from the market adaptation of individual firms to the continuous transactional relationships between lead firms and their suppliers; the forms of spillover have broadened from product specifications to encompass process standards such as disclosure, due diligence, auditing, and data interfaces; and the outcomes manifest as adjustments to supplier access, order allocation, investment distribution, and network structures. Compared to voluntary supply chain codes of conduct, its key incremental contribution stems from the liability structure established by public law.
The lead enterprises on chains face risks related to administrative enforcement, civil liability, and reputation; consequently, questionnaires, audits, certifications, and data systems maintain sustained enforceability.
The formation of the “Brussels effect on value chains” requires three conditions: the EU must possess sufficient market appeal and predictable market access rules; regulations must include procedural provisions that are actionable, quantifiable, or verifiable; and lead firms must hold governance powers regarding order allocation, technical specifications, data access, audit-driven rectification, and market exit. The strength of this effect is further influenced by market substitutability, product traceability, policy stability, and the power structure within value chains. When enterprises can rapidly pivot to other markets, products and supply chains are separable, metrics lack credible verification, or upstream supplies are highly concentrated or irreplaceable, the spillover of rules tends to remain localized or shift toward negotiation-based adaptation. Automobiles, batteries, critical materials, and recycled plastics feature strong traceability, while European vehicle manufacturers possess centralized procurement and interface control capabilities; these sectors therefore serve as suitable areas for observing this effect.
- The horizontal-vertical coupling of EU automotive sustainability standards
The EU’s framework for sustainable corporate governance is underpinned by a foundation of mandatory transparency. The corporate sustainability reporting regime, based on the principle of double materiality, requires large enterprises to disclose the impacts of their operations on the environment and society, as well as the risks and opportunities that sustainability issues pose to their financial position; the due diligence regime mandates that companies identify, prevent, mitigate, and account for environmental risks within their own operations, subsidiaries, and value chains; and rules on assurance and standardized reporting criteria enhance the comparability and verifiability of information. The EU’s subsequent decision to narrow the scope of application and delay implementation through comprehensive simplification measures demonstrates that regulatory spillover effects adjust in response to competitiveness, administrative burdens, and political-economic trade-offs. While changes in the implementation pace of cross-cutting regulations may affect the investment decisions of lead firms regarding supply chain data collection and audit system development, factors such as product regulations, customer requirements, financing constraints, and reputational risks continue to drive large enterprises to take proactive action.
Regarding raw materials, the “Critical Raw Materials Act” aims to reduce reliance on strategic raw materials through targets for extraction, processing, recycling, and supply source diversification, while due diligence frameworks incorporate environmental risk identification and supply chain management into corporate responsibilities. At the design and production stages, the “Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation” integrates requirements concerning durability, repairability, upgradability, recycled content, and carbon and environmental footprints into product standards, and it introduces the Digital Product Passport. The Digital Product Passport enables information relating to material sourcing, composition, carbon emissions, repairability, and recyclability to travel with the product as an electronic record, providing a unified interface for customs authorities, manufacturers, recyclers, and regulators.
The EU’s vertical product regulations for sustainable automotive governance translate abstract goals into concrete thresholds. The Battery Regulation covers the entire battery lifecycle, mandating carbon footprint declarations, minimum recycled material content, due diligence for critical raw materials, and battery passports. Once the relevant requirements take effect, manufacturers will be required to collect and verify data spanning the entire value chain, from raw material extraction and refining to the production of battery cells and packs. Products will carry their own compliance records, allowing regulators to access information via QR codes and data interfaces, while manufacturers bear the responsibility for generating, verifying, and updating this data. Upstream activities that previously were difficult for EU authorities to oversee directly are thus transformed into a mandatory chain of evidence that must be submitted prior to market entry.
The “End-of-Life Vehicle Regulation” extends circular economy requirements to the end-of-life stage of vehicles, thereby influencing vehicle design and material procurement. Requirements regarding the proportion of recycled plastics, closed-loop recycling sources, dismantling information, material labeling, and extended producer responsibility collectively constitute circularity constraints. Vehicle manufacturers need to consider ease of dismantling and recyclability during the vehicle development phase, require suppliers to verify the content and origin of recycled materials during procurement, and establish verifiable partnerships with companies involved in dismantling, sorting, recycling, and material recovery. Consequently, end-of-life recycling becomes a key factor influencing upstream design and supplier selection.
The EU also employs complementary measures such as the “Euro 7” emission standards, vehicle CO2 emission standards, and the Net-Zero Industry Act. “Euro 7” brings particulate matter from brake and tire wear under regulatory control; vehicle CO2 standards drive electrification through heavy fines; and the Net-Zero Industry Act incorporates non-price criteria such as sustainability, supply chain resilience, cybersecurity, and delivery capabilities into public procurement and related tenders. Whether an enterprise can enter the market or secure orders increasingly depends on its ability to consistently demonstrate compliance. In doing so, the EU has linked raw materials, design, production, usage, and recycling into a regulatory network spanning the entire product life cycle.
- Value chain integration mechanisms: case studies on battery passports and recycled materials from end-of-life vehicles
“Non-price standards” exert binding force through verifiable processes. Regulations first translate environmental objectives into disclosure templates, due diligence questionnaires, carbon footprint methodologies, recycled content ratios, bills of materials, and risk classification rules. The lead enterprises on chains then incorporate these requirements into supplier onboarding, tiered management, contractual terms, audit plans, and data traceability protocols, and suppliers demonstrate compliance through third-party assurance, certification, and traceability records. Failure to meet compliance requirements can impact contract awards, orders, eligibility for corrective actions, and market access. The restructuring of processes, products, organizations, and data undertaken by enterprises to overcome these hurdles constitutes a mandatory environmental upgrade.
The battery passport case exemplifies the concept of “locking in upstream data.” Requirements under the Battery Regulation regarding carbon footprint, recycled content, and due diligence extend transactions between vehicle manufacturers and battery suppliers beyond traditional parameters such as price, quality, and delivery time. Carbon footprint accounting necessitates the sharing of data on energy, processes, transportation, and raw materials among vehicle manufacturers, battery companies, and material suppliers. Requirements regarding recycled content necessitate corporate participation in recycling systems and material development, while mineral due diligence mandates require suppliers to establish mechanisms for risk identification, mitigation, grievance handling, auditing, and record-keeping. Consequently, supply chain leaders strengthen their control over suppliers through data standards and audit protocols.
Corporate disclosures illustrate this translation process. Volkswagen centers its approach on supplier sustainability ratings, integrating suppliers into processes that include self-assessment questionnaires, risk analysis, on-site audits, and the tracking of corrective actions, while linking rating results to contract award eligibility. Mercedes-Benz and Stellantis strengthen supply chain oversight through on-site inspections, third-party assessments, and audits of high-risk suppliers. CATL integrates its Supplier Code of Conduct with procurement contracts and conducts mineral supply chain due diligence and third-party on-site audits. Meanwhile, Gotion High-Tech has transformed the pressures regarding carbon footprints and raw material compliance stemming from EU battery regulations into internal response systems, active participation in standard-setting, and a strategic production footprint in Europe. These practices demonstrate how EU requirements are incorporated into routine procurement management through the rating, auditing, corrective action, and data integration processes of supply chain leaders, while upstream suppliers internalize compliance as a core organizational capability.
The targets for recycled materials in end-of-life vehicles embody a “downstream-to-upstream” circularity approach. Vehicle manufacturers first translate recycled material content and closed-loop ratios into material specifications, procurement KPIs, and contract award criteria, requiring suppliers to establish an evidentiary chain linking source, batch, and application, and provide third-party certification. Secondly, requirements for dismantling information and material identification are integrated across the design, production, and recycling phases. Lead enterprises embed material declarations, dismantling guidelines, and recyclability parameters into component data and vehicle development processes; suppliers submit information based on standardized protocols and interface with industry databases or corporate platforms. Furthermore, Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) compels vehicle manufacturers to manage the end-of-life disposal process and establish long-term partnerships with qualified dismantling, sorting, and recycling enterprises that possess verifiable capabilities. Finally, as recycled content, sourcing, and quality are verified through certification, spot checks, and batch traceability, companies capable of consistently providing both certification and data are more likely to retain orders, whereas suppliers lacking a verifiable chain of evidence face the risk of being replaced.
The two sub-cases illustrate the same mechanism. Horizontal institutions establish an accountability framework, clarifying responsibilities, disclosure requirements, and accountability mechanisms; vertical regulations provide verifiable metrics such as carbon footprint, recycled content, disassembly information, and recycling destinations. Lead firms employ contractual, verifiable, and data-driven tools to harden these provisions: the contractual approach manifests as award thresholds, deadlines for corrective action, and information disclosure obligations. Verifiability is manifested through questionnaires, on-site inspections, third-party certifications, and report assurance; data integration is reflected in product passport fields, system interface connectivity, access management, and traceability records. When these tools are linked to order allocation and market access qualifications, suppliers are required to continuously generate compliance data and improve their production processes.
This process is reshaping global value chain governance. Information that is complex, dynamic, and difficult to fully codify raises transaction costs, driving lead firms and suppliers to shift from market-based or modular relationships toward closer relational or captive arrangements. Low-carbon processes, circular design, traceability, assurance, and data governance have become prerequisites for market access, while the basis of competition has expanded from “price and technology” to “price, technology, and compliance capability.” Value chain outcomes include supplier screening, order reallocation, localization investments, the formation of recovery networks, and path dependency in data infrastructure. Regulation has evolved from point-in-time product inspections to the governance of continuous processes spanning procurement, production, delivery, and recovery.
- The impact on China and the policy implications
Chinese automotive, battery, and materials companies need to integrate compliance capabilities into their long-term operations. First, companies must build the necessary infrastructure for data management and assurance. They should organize data regarding raw material batches, energy, manufacturing processes, logistics, and recycling; standardize methodologies for life-cycle assessment, emission factors, recycled content, and risk classification; and embed the chain of evidence into their information systems to ensure alignment with product passport specifications and customer interface requirements. Third-party assurance and industry mutual recognition can be introduced for high-risk processes to reduce redundant audits. The value of such things lies in establishing a data foundation that can be reused across clients and regulatory frameworks.
Second, enterprises need to continuously advance technological improvements and upgrades in materials and circularity. They should implement retrofits for energy efficiency, electrification, and low-carbon energy adoption in high-emission processes; develop automotive-grade recycled materials; establish closed-loop systems for sorting, recycling, and remanufacturing in partnership with recycling firms; and integrate requirements for ease of disassembly, repair, and recyclability into the R&D review stage. Stable low-carbon processes and a closed-loop material supply can enhance bargaining power and secure qualifications for continuous supply.
Third, enterprises need to restructure their ecosystem networks and organizational capabilities. They can integrate into networks for European certification, green energy, and compliant recycling and participate in data spaces and industry alliances led by key supply chain leaders through joint ventures, M&A, or strategic production positioning across segments such as batteries, critical components, and recycling. Internally, they must foster a coordinated mechanism among procurement, R&D, legal, IT, and sustainability departments to accelerate their response to audits, corrective actions, and customer communications.
Fourth, enterprises need to proactively participate in the formulation of rules and standards. Companies should monitor changes regarding the scope, methodologies, and implementation details of EU regulations. Through channels such as industry associations, product passport pilots, data spaces, and standards development, they should strive to ensure the operational feasibility of data fields, algorithms, and audit criteria. Simultaneously, they should conduct scenario assessments to adjust their procurement, investment, customer, and market portfolios in advance. Active participation in rule-making can mitigate the reactive costs associated with regulatory changes.
Fifth, the government and industry associations need to provide public goods related to compliance. The government can facilitate the development of standards for carbon accounting, circularity data, and product passports that are compatible with EU methodologies. It can foster independent and credible third-party assurance capabilities and support ancillary sectors such as recycling, materials, and data services through policies aimed at helping green industries expand internationally. Industry organizations, meanwhile, can jointly develop data interfaces and interoperability platforms, promote the alignment and mutual recognition of certification systems and accounting methodologies, organize joint pilot projects involving supply chain leaders, suppliers, recyclers, and assurance bodies, and provide standardized tools, training, and risk early-warning services to small and medium-sized enterprises.
Translated by Thomas E. Smith
Note:
Chen Yushi is a postdoctoral researcher at the Antai College of Economics and Management, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, and a distinguished researcher at the Tiangong Think Tank Center of the Tsinghua Suzhou Institute of Environmental Innovation; Liu Hongsong is a professor at the School of International and Public Affairs, Shanghai Jiao Tong University.
This article was originally published in Ouzhou yanjiu (Chinese Journal of European Studies), 2026(2): 35-73. This is an abridged translation.
